Could the Decisions of Your Managers Make Put Your Business at Risk? 
 
How recent changes to the Crime and Policing Act have created an important leadership conversation — and why your managers may be more exposed than you think. 
 
When we work with business owners and senior leaders, we rarely start by asking about policies, procedures or legislation. 
We ask a much simpler question. 
 
Who really makes the important decisions in your business? 
The answer is almost never as straightforward as people expect. 
 
Most people immediately point to the Managing Director. But the reality is that important decisions are made every day by operational managers, project leaders, site supervisors, and departmental heads. They decide whether work starts. Whether a process continues. Whether equipment stays in service. Whether a contractor gets the green light. Whether a level of risk is acceptable. 
 
Most of those decisions are made with the very best intentions to keep customers happy, solve problems, and hit deadlines. 
 
But every now and then, an operational decision quietly becomes a health and safety decision. 
 
Recognising that moment is one of the most important leadership skills any business can develop. 
 
Why This Matters Right Now 
Recent changes to the Crime and Policing Act have broadened the way criminal liability can be attributed to organisations. In simple terms: if a senior manager commits a criminal offence while acting within the scope of their authority, the organisation itself may also face criminal liability. 
 
For health and safety professionals, that's a significant development. 
 
But here's the thing we don't see this as simply a legal story. 
 
We see it as a leadership story. 
 
The legislation hasn't created new health and safety responsibilities. Those responsibilities have always existed. What it has done is shine an even brighter spotlight on the quality of leadership behind the decisions your business makes every single day. 
 
Who Actually Counts as a Senior Manager? 
This is where many businesses need to pause and really think. 
 
Don't just picture directors or executives. 
 
The definition is based far more on influence and responsibility than on job titles. For many businesses, a senior manager could be anyone with meaningful authority to direct people, manage operations, allocate resources, or make decisions that affect how work gets done. 
 
So, ask yourself honestly: who in your business has the authority to make decisions that could affect the safety of other people? 
 
The answer may be a much longer list than you first expected. 
 
Leadership Is Tested in Ordinary Moments 
Very few serious incidents begin with someone intending to do the wrong thing. 
 
They usually begin with someone trying to solve today's problem. 
 
A project is running behind. A repair is delayed. A contractor is asked to start before everything is in place. Someone accepts a shortcut because it feels quicker, easier, or commercially necessary. 
 
These aren't unusual situations they happen in businesses every single week. 
 
The real question is: would your managers recognise the moment when an operational decision becomes a health and safety decision? 
Because that is exactly the point at which leadership matters most. 
 
Meet James 
James is an operations manager at a mid-sized manufacturing firm. Fifteen years of experience. Trusted by the business. Gets things done. 
One afternoon, a production line goes down. There's pressure to get it running again before the end of shift a key customer order is at stake. A contractor who's on site offers to start a repair, even though one part of the permit-to-work process hasn't been signed off. James weighs it up. Nothing has gone wrong before. The contractor seems confident. The clock is ticking. 
 
He gives the go-ahead. 
 
Fortunately, nothing happened that afternoon. But James made a health and safety decision and didn't realise it. He didn't know when to stop and escalate. And in a different outcome, the consequences for him, the business, and most importantly the contractor, could have been very serious indeed. 
 
James isn't reckless. He's a good manager. But nobody had ever clearly told him where the line was. 
 
This Isn't About Creating Fear 
Every time legislation changes, there's a rush to produce another policy, another procedure, another training course. 
 
We're not convinced that's where the biggest opportunity lies. 
 
The businesses that handle this best create something far more valuable than paperwork. They create clarity. 
 
Their managers understand the limits of their authority. They know when to stop. They know when to ask for help. They know when a decision needs to go upstairs. And they understand without any ambiguity that commercial pressure should never override a critical safety decision. 
That isn't compliance. 
 
That's leadership. 
 
Three Conversations Worth Having This Week 
Rather than checking whether your paperwork is up to date, try asking your leadership team these three questions: 
 
Who in our business can make decisions that significantly affect health and safety? 
Would every one of those people know when to stop and escalate a concern? 
If an investigator visited tomorrow, would they find evidence of thoughtful leadership or just completed paperwork? 
Those conversations will probably tell you far more about your business than any audit ever could. 
 
Navigator Reflection 
Take a moment to think about your own business. 
 
If one of your managers had to make a difficult decision this afternoon... 
 
Would they understand the limits of their authority? Would they know when to ask for support? Would they have the confidence to stop the job if they believed someone could be seriously harmed? 
 
If you're not completely sure, perhaps that's the conversation your business needs to have next. 
 
Start Your Navigator Journey 
Leadership isn't about having every answer. It's about asking better questions before difficult decisions have to be made. 
 
That's exactly why we created the Navigator Programme. 
 
Navigator helps business owners and senior leaders understand where they are today, identify opportunities for improvement, and develop the leadership behaviours that create safer, stronger, and more resilient organisations. 
 
The first step is simple. 
 
Complete our free Navigator Questionnaire. 
 
It isn't an audit. It isn't a test. It's the beginning of a leadership conversation that could transform the way your business thinks about health and safety. 
 
 
 
Because moving from compliance to confidence doesn't begin with more paperwork. It begins with better leadership conversations. 
Share this post:

Leave a comment: